It’s odd, and it took some serious meditation and self reflection to come to this, but there is a serious division that exists in how I think about beer. There’s beer and then there is Beer. The previous is the stuff we buy in the can or the bottle with the screw-top cap (noting some exceptions). This is the stuff that we drink at a rock show or watch a NASCAR race with or drink as a LunchBeer when we don’t want to pass out under your desk later. For me this is PBR for others it’s the High Life, a division that demands further exploration, but we’ll save that for later. For most of the American population it’s Bud or Miller. The other, Beer, of course is what we usually discuss here, it’s the stuff you enjoy rolling slowly across your tongue. Now, this is where it get’s interesting, we spend more time with this style of beer than any other and in my experience the same people that know enough to determine a dark lager from a brown ale or a Belgian witte from a Belgian blonde occasionally have a tough time identifying the type of beer that our American macro breweries produce. I am no exception to this rule, for a very long time if I was pushed to give an answer on this question I’d say… oh it’s an American Pilsner, hoping not to get caught. Lately it started to bug me that though it became apparent to me that it is actually an American Golden Lager I didn’t really understand how it fit into the greater world of beer. I thought of it like marshmallows or Vegimite or fruit roll-ups, you know, they kind of are what they are, they have unpronounceable ingredients and are made up mostly of a combination of preservatives, synthetic materials, and sawdust… they don’t really have a category per se. So I offer the following explanation by way of the battle between Luke and Darth Vader from Return of the Jedi:
117 EMPEROR Macrobrew’S TOWER - THRONE ROOM 117
Luke Pilswalker and Golden LagVader are engaged in a man-to-man duel of lightsabers… um, pint glasses. But Pilswalker has grown stronger in the interim, with the passage of the Pop the Cap Bill and now the advantage shifts to him. LagVader is forced back, losing his balance. Luke Pilswalker stands at the top of the stairs, ready to attack.
EMPEROR Macro (laughing)
Good. Use your aggressive feelings and good pallet, boy! Let the hate flow through you like a clean tap.
Luke Pilswalker looks momentarily toward the Emperor, then back to LagVader, and realizes he is using the dark (read - ultra light) side. He steps back, turns off lightsaber…. um, pint glass and relaxes, driving the hate from his being.
LUKE PILSWALKER
I will not fight you, for you are simply another style of beer.
LAGVADER
You are unwise to lower your defenses.
LagVader attacks, with superbowl ads forcing Luke Pilswalker on the defensive. The young Jedi leaps in an amazing reverse flip up to the safety of the catwalk overhead. LagVader stands below him.
LUKE PILSWALKER
I feel the good in you…it’s so light and barely detectable, but I can taste the hops and sweet barley.
LAGVADER
There are little to no carbs here…
It wasn’t long ago I too was a pure style like yourself. We share so much in common. Our malt is the same, only our hops distance our styles.
LagVader stops and senses something. Luke Pilswalker shuts his eyes tightly, in anguish.
LAGVADER
Ah, I see you are trying to deny it, but the only difference between you and I is that your hops are from Eastern Europe, Saaz hops. Mine are cheaper and from Eastern Wissconson. Come Luke, come to the Dark (read ultra-light) side and lend your style’s name to establish the Macro Empire as even more profitable!
LUKE PILSWALKER
Never-r-r!
Luke Pilswalker ignites his lightsaber… um…pint glass and screams in anger, rushes at LagVader with a frenzy. The Dark Lord is knocked to his knees, and as he raises his pint glass to block another onslaught, Luke Pilswalker slashes LagVader’s right hand off at the wrist, causing preservatives and electronic parts to fly from the mechanical stump. LagVader’s pint glass clatters uselessly away, over the edge of the platform and into the bottomless shaft below. Luke Pilswalker moves over LagVader and holds the blade of his pint glass to the Dark Lord’s throat.
LUKE PILSWALKER
I’ll recognize that the American Golden Lager has it’s place. Though technically a Pilsner is a type of Pale or Golden Lager, I will continue to define myself based on the soft water used to make me and my noble hops; floral, but not too bitter.
At least do me the favor of not referring to your beers as “Pilsner Styled”… that really confuses folks.
LAGVADER
Your feeble demands are no match for the power of popular advertising. Hmm, but I think this metaphor has run it’s course. Perhaps we should just call it a day.
Well, in retrospect i’m not sure how informative that really was, but it was fun. If you want to read more about the pilsner story the wikipedia post provides a good frame.
May the Pours be with you!